How to Choose the Right Toy for Your Dog’s Size & Personality

How to Choose the Right Toy for Your Dog’s Size & Personality

🐾 Every Dog Needs the Right Toy

Not all toys work for all dogs.
A tug toy that’s perfect for a pitbull might overwhelm a small Maltese.
A squeaker toy that excites an energetic terrier might bore a laid-back senior dog.

Choosing the right toy keeps your dog:
✔ Happy
✔ Mentally stimulated
✔ Physically active
✔ SAFE

Let’s break it down!

🐕 1. Choose by Size (Safety First!)

🐶 Small Dogs (Under 20 lbs)

✔ Lightweight plush toys
✔ Small balls
✔ Mini chew toys
Avoid heavy rubber toys — too hard on jaws.

🐕 Medium Dogs (20–50 lbs)

✔ Rope toys
✔ Medium rubber chew toys
✔ Treat-dispensing puzzles

🐩 Large / XL Dogs (50+ lbs)

✔ Thick rope toys
✔ Durable rubber toys (non-toxic!)
✔ Tough chew rings

❗Always choose toys larger than your dog’s mouth to prevent choking.

🧠 2. Choose by Personality Type

🐾 The Chewer

Likes: destroying, gnawing
Best Toys:

  • Tough rubber chews

  • Nylon bones

  • Rope toys

Explore our Extreme Chewer Set
👉 [Shop Chew Toys]

🎾 The Fetch Lover

Always chasing balls & flying objects
Best Toys:

  • Rubber balls

  • Lightweight discs

  • Indoor-safe plush fetch toys

🧩 The Thinker

Loves puzzles & problem-solving
Best Toys:

  • Treat puzzles

  • Snuffle mats

  • Slow feeders

Try our Brain Play Puzzle Bundle
👉 [Explore Puzzle Toys]

🤗 The Cuddler

These dogs love soft textures and comfort
Best Toys:

  • Plush toys

  • Stuffed animals

  • Soft squeakers

⚡ The Energy Rocket

High-energy dogs need engagement
Best Toys:

  • Tug-of-war ropes

  • Fetch balls

  • Sturdy squeakers

  • Interactive toys

🐶 3. Check Material Safety

Look for:
✔ BPA-free rubber
✔ Non-toxic dyes
✔ Reinforced stitching
✔ Durable materials

Avoid:
🚫 Very cheap plastic
🚫 Toys that shed fibers
🚫 Cooked bones (splinter hazard)

🧼 4. Rotate Toys Weekly

Rotating toys keeps your dog interested and prevents boredom.
You don’t need more toys — just smarter rotation.

✨ Final Thoughts

Your dog’s perfect toy depends on their size, bite strength, and personality.
With the right toys, you’ll boost physical activity, mental stimulation, and overall happiness.

🐾 Find your dog’s perfect toy at WhiskerBoxPet.com 🐾
👉 Chew toys, puzzles, plushies, and more!

Back to blog